diff --git a/app/Http/Controllers/PublicController.php b/app/Http/Controllers/PublicController.php
index 91a2db10..d0d2fd23 100644
--- a/app/Http/Controllers/PublicController.php
+++ b/app/Http/Controllers/PublicController.php
@@ -51,26 +51,41 @@ class PublicController extends Controller
     public function showCategoryEvents($cat_id){
 
         [$order, $data] = $this->sorts_filters();
-        $category = Category::select('id','title_tk','title_ru')
+        $category = Category::select('id','title_tk','title_ru','events_limit')
             ->with(['children' => function($query) use($data,$order){
                 $query->whereHas('cat_events',
                     function ($query) use($data){
                         $query->onLive($data['start'], $data['end']);
-                    })
-                    ->with(['cat_events' => function($q) use($data,$order){
-                        $q->onLive($data['start'], $data['end'],8)
-                            ->orderBy($order['field'],$order['order']);
-                    }]);
+                    });
+//                    ->with(['cat_events' => function($q) use($data,$order){
+//                        $q->onLive($data['start'], $data['end'])
+//                            ->orderBy($order['field'],$order['order']);
+//                    }]);
 //                $query->withLiveEvents($order, $data['start'], $data['end']);
 
             }])
             ->findOrFail($cat_id);
 
-        dd($category);
+        $sub_cats = $category->children;
+
+        $sub_cats_events = $sub_cats->pop()
+            ->cat_events()
+            ->onLive($data['start'],$data['end'])
+            ->orderBy($order['field'],$order['order'])
+            ->take($category->events_limit);
+
+        foreach ($sub_cats as $sub_cat){
+            $events = $sub_cat->cat_events()
+                ->onLive($data['start'],$data['end'])
+                ->orderBy($order['field'],$order['order'])
+                ->take($category->events_limit);
+            $sub_cats_events = $sub_cats_events->unionAll($events);
+        }
+
+        dd($sub_cats_events->get());
 
         $data['category'] = $category;
 
-        $sub_cats = $category->children->first();
         $data['sub_cats'] = $category->children()
             ->withLiveEvents($order, $data['start'], $data['end'], $category->events_limit)//wiered
             ->whereHas('cat_events',
diff --git a/app/Models/Event.php b/app/Models/Event.php
index f3c2f589..b2d68051 100644
--- a/app/Models/Event.php
+++ b/app/Models/Event.php
@@ -490,7 +490,7 @@ ICSTemplate;
         return (is_null($this->access_codes()->where('id', $accessCodeId)->first()) === false);
     }
 
-    public function scopeOnLive($query, $start_date = null, $end_date = null,$limit = false){
+    public function scopeOnLive($query, $start_date = null, $end_date = null){
         //if date is null carbon creates now date instance
         //todo what if only end date is null??
         if(!empty($start_date) && !empty($end_date))
@@ -500,8 +500,6 @@ ICSTemplate;
         }
         else
             $query->where('end_date','>',Carbon::now(config('app.timezone')));
-        if($limit)
-            $query->take($limit);
 
         return $query->where('is_live',1)
             ->withCount(['images as image_url' => function($q){